Sunday, February 22, 2015

YCS Tacoma Recap + PPTQ Top 8 Report

I was actually going to post a Tacoma recap last Sunday but it was covered and talked about so much on Youtube that I felt that it would be kind of redundant. The big takeaway from the event was obviously Nekroz, as they took an overwhelming 22 out of the top 32 spots with Shaddolls and Satellas nowhere to be seen in the top 32. My guess that Qlis would be the 2nd most represented deck was correct; I thought BA would do a little better but Nekroz proved to be too bad of a match-up for them. What I was actually most surprised about was there being so many people with complete Nekroz decks due to the absurdly low pull rates of Brionac, Valkyrus and Trishula. I figured most people wouldn't have been able to complete them but I guess if you throw enough money at something it'll work out in the end. I'm glad I'm not in it anymore to have to shell out that kind of money if I wanted to play the best deck. Two local players from my area ended up making day 2 but unfortunately no one on the team did and no one locally managed to top 32. Moving forward I envision the era of Nekroz domination to continue over the next several months since chances are slim the upcoming March list will do anything to the deck. The interesting thing about tier 0 formats is the tech that will inevitably come out of them, an aspect that still excites me where I get to be like "wow I never thought that card would see play".

Yesterday I played in a local Preliminary Pro Tour Qualifier (PPTQ) for Magic and managed to make top 8. I think this was only like my 3rd or 4th tournament back into the game so I was very proud of my accomplishment even though I'm still kicking myself over the sub-optimal plays I made which cost me my top 8 match. Rather than doing a whole elaborate tournament report I'll go over the events leading up to the event, what I played at the event, and moving forward.

So the 3 tournaments I played in prior to the PPTQ were 2 FNMs and 1 Tuesday tournament. Besides some playtesting that's all the Magic I've been able to play. My first FNM was with Mardu where I went 2-2 and promptly sold the deck off. The next tournament I played Abzan Aggro and went a terrible 1-3. Now at this point I'm sure you could feel my frustration; I have won a 200+ man regional (albiet that was 8 years ago now) and at one time was ranked 4th in the entire state. I felt like I shouldn't be doing this terrible and began questioning my deck choice, if I was even playing Magic correctly, should I just go back to YGO, etc. Admittedly I haven't been able to put in a lot of time testing but I felt like I had a decent enough understanding of the deck and playing Magic in general that I shouldn't be doing this bad. I contemplated playing Abzan Midrange since midrange has always been my favorite sort of deck to play (not too aggressive but not entirely control-based) and bought the stuff I needed to build that deck. But after testing a bit on Virtual Playtable (basically Magic Workstation) I thought the deck was entirely too slow vs Red-White unless it could stick out a Courser and drop land over a few turns to gain some life or something like double Rhino. End Hostilities was just too slow vs the deck, which is when I realized that there's a world of difference between a 4-cost Wrath and a 5-cost Wrath. The extra turn of potential damage really does add up. I made the switch back to Abzan Aggro (which is kind of poorly named now that I think about it, I will talk about that later), and playtested with it online some more while also doing some research on Jeskai and Mono Red.

Flash forward to like a week or 2 later and I played in the Tuesday tournament last Tuesday when I finally got to play in a tourney with Danny, Corey, Senior, and Shiggs all present. It was nice playing in a tourney with a good chunk of the team there. Shiggs and Danny ended up going 4-1 and I ended up going 3-2. I was actually very content with this performance because my losses were to Jeskai Ascendancy combo and Esper Control. The combo deck ended up winning the tourney where no one could stop it from going off on like turn 2 or 3 and it was just whatever. No one takes losing to that deck into much consideration since it isn't concerned with actually interacting with you. As for my loss vs Esper, it was against someone that is highly regarded in the community both as a judge and player (and all-around good guy) and I did give him a hell of a run in our game 2. If it weren't for his Angel that put him back to 20 life I should've been able to take a game. I was still able to make top 8 due to awesome tie-breakers and it reaffirmed me that I did indeed know how to play Magic and I wasn't playing a deck that just wasn't for me. I think my past results stemmed from poor mulligan choices where I'd keep poor hands just because of being afraid to go down a card.

As for the PPTQ, there were 38 players. I was surprised at the low turnout because the PTQ the week prior had about 80. I guess the change in qualifying structure turned a lot of people off or they just didn't want to shell out another $20 to play after coming off a PTQ the week before.

Round 1: Mardu L 1-2
Game 1 he gets stuck on 3 land and I'm able to overtake him with board presence.
Game 2 is pretty back and forth but I can't keep his fliers in check and he takes it.
Game 3 I keep a 6-card hand that has Forest, Plains, 3 double-black cards (2 Blight 1 Sorrow), and a Siege Rhino. In all honesty this was my mistake and for some reason I thought I could either draw into an Urborg to make my double-black cards live or draw 2 lands to drop a Rhino. Neither of those things happened and I quickly lost the game.
This is exactly what I am talking about when it comes to my poor mulligan choices and I should have gone to 5. I have an inherent fear of going down to 5 cards, but what I need to remember is that losing with a crappy 6 is the same result as losing due to having to go to 5. But with a good 5 you still have the chance to win (hell I have won with going down to 4 before) so it's better to just take that chance. I was also disappointed losing to this person because I could tell he wasn't very good and he made it apparent when he told me something along the lines of "I hope to see you in the finals but I've never finished very well even at locals". At the end of the day he ended up going 3-3, so yea, felt like I got YGO'd there.

Round 2: Sultai W 2-1
Game 1 he drops an early Kiora that I'm unable to deal with and in a few turns gets her ultimate off. I try to play for a few more turns but I can't deal with free 9/9's that come down every turn and scoop it up.
Game 2 he doesn't get much going and I end the game at 40 life between Rhinos, Courser, and Sorin.
Game 3 he had sided into a more aggro-ish build using Deathdealers and makes a crucial misplay by Bile Blight'ing my Deathdealer when he is attacking with his. We go back and forth but I outlast him and draw removal for his things while he doesn't.

Round 3: Mardu W 2-1
Game 1 he gets stuck on 2 land and I curve out pretty much perfectly.
Game 2 I keep a slow hand and don't get anything going as he spot removals my guys while also churning out a board.
Game 3 I'm able to keep his Rabblemasters in check and he doesn't get much going so I take the game fairly easily.

Round 4: Black-White Tokens W 2-1
Game 1 is fairly back and forth but he makes a big board with Monastery Mentor and plays the instant that does X damage and he gains X life where X is the number of creatures he has in play.
Game 2 a lot of "you take life I gain life" shifts between my Sorin and Wingmate, and his creature where I take 1 for each attacking creature while he gains that life. Eventually I out-resource him though and Bile Blight/Drown in Sorrow are just too good vs token decks.
Game 3 Similar to game 2 but he makes a crucial misplay of tapping out for Mentor when he knew I had Drown in hand (revealed off Courser). This puts me ahead in advantage while he's topdecking.
This was definitely my hardest Swiss match of the day and it especially sucked since I had to go pee like halfway through game 1 and by the end of game 3 I was scrambling to put my stuff away and go lol.

Round 5: Mardu W 2-0
Game 1 he gets stuck on 2 land (this has been a recurring thing with my Mardu matches lol) and doesn't get anything going.
Game 2 I'm able to deal with his guys as he plays them and I out resource him.
This guy had top 8'd the previous PTQ so this win was great for me.

At this point they post the standings and I was 7th. All of the 4-1's that were paired against each other would be able to split and make top 8, so I thought I was good, but I was the 4-1 that got the downpair so I had to play and chances were if I lost I wouldn't make it (didn't help that my 1 loss was way down toward the last tables).

Round 6: Blue Black W 2-0
Before we started I asked the guy if he could even top if he won and naturally his buddy next to him was all like "Yup! He would definitely top because he has the highest tie-breaker at this point!" From what I've experienced through years of card games is it doesn't always work like that and was fairly sure that even if he had won he would've gotten like 10th, so in my mind I was thinking it would've been nice if he had just given me the win but he didn't seem to have any sort of inclination of doing so so we just went for it.
Game 1 I stick an early Fleecemane out that goes unchecked for a few turns and I bait his counters out with disposable cards while resolving my better threats and take the game fairly swiftly.
Game 2 we both mull to 5 which I am perfectly fine with since Blue needs its cards more than Aggro does. This game ends up going fairly long but I basically end up resolving all 4 Rhinos (last one tutored off Liliana and resolves for game).
I think that I, as someone that played in the Mono Blue Meloku/Kamigawa days, have enough experience against counterspell decks that I can bait stuff out and play stuff when they're tapped out appropriately. I see so many players play Dig in their Main Phase, just to add more instants that I think playing against Blue in this era is just so much easier compared to a format where you had Spell Snare, Mana Leak, Remand, Hinder, Rewind, etc all present.

So having to play in the 6th round put me at 15 points and I finished 2nd in Swiss. At this point I was just beyond happy to make top 8 and to get prizing that was worth more than my entry fee. I was starting to think that I could take the whole damn thing.

Top 8: Jeskai L 1-2
Game 1 I get stuck on 3 land while he's burning me and swinging at me with Mantis Riders and stuff. I'm at 6 life and discard a Thoughtseize I drew into at my end phase and he literally scoffs and shakes his head. I'm just like "what, I play Thoughtseize so you can Stoke me for game?" His turn he attacks and Stokes me. In my mind I call him a faggot.
Game 2 He gets stuck on 3 land and I'm able to spot removal whatever he plays.
Game 3 I get over-zealous with my Abzan Charms (they aren't just Pot of Greeds) and I eat a Sarkhan hit rather than using Charm to exile it. Since I had a Downfall in hand, my thought process was I should use the Charm to draw into stuff since I could Downfall the Sarkhan on my turn while hoping to draw into a Rhino or Sorin to re-stabilize my life. He was low on cards since he had been using his cards to burn me and didn't have board presence while I had a Deathdealer and a Lion. On the last turn he was at 9 life with 1 card in hand, while I'm at 3 life and had Deathdealer and Lion on the board, and like 4 cards in hand. I swing and pump my Dealer to 6 for lethal but he has Jeskai Charm to Wing Blast my Dealer to the top. Due to the pumps I only had 4 mana open so I couldn't cast Wingmate Roc and I was holding a Downfall I believe because I was scared of Mantis Rider. He topdecks Dig Through Time and my heart sunk a bit but I had a little hope that his top 7 would be blanks, but sure enough he revealed a Lightning Strike for game.
What I should have done is spare myself the 6 life by Charm'ing his Sarkhan and drop a Raided Wingmate Roc to try and gain life that way, instead of holding mana free for removal on a potential Mantis Rider (cuz the Roc can just block the Rider after all) which he never drew into anyway. This was a hard lesson learned but still a lesson learned so it is something I will never forget about moving forward.

I get 12 packs for prizing but have no intention of opening them because I'm on that 4 or 5-year plan with hopes of selling the packs at $13+ each, instead of hoping to be lucky to pull like 2 fetches at most which is unlikely in itself.

Moving forward I'm not entirely sure on what I'll be playing although I think I'm getting the swing of things with Abzan "Aggro". When I think of aggro in the typical sense, I think of Jeskai, Red-White, Mono-Red and those kinds of decks. Abzan Aggro is not like those and is much more controlling in nature. Typically "aggro" decks don't run 4 or 5 mana cost creatures unless they have haste while Abzan runs the full gamut of Rhinos and Rocs. I also incorporated 2 Coursers into my build which I absolutely love since they potentially help me in the life department and put me further in cards and smooth out my mana. I actually think Abzan Aggro should be called Abzan Midrange, and the Midrange deck should be called Control. But you pretty much have to be Blue and be running counterspells to be considered Control in this game. I guess the builds with Warden could be "aggro" since at least it's a 1-drop. I might try Heir of the Wilds in the future since the Deathtouch aspect of it seems pretty decent on paper. I just didn't want to make their Wild Slashes too live but again I'm not entirely sure yet. I'm also slowly building Mono Red as a trolly "idgaf" deck but with the rise in popularity of Jeskai/Red-White I'm not sure how that will pan out. Ideally Mono Red would be good in a field with a lot of midrange, at least I think, I'm not even entirely sure lol. I just know it has the potential to do a lot of damage really quickly and is basically the cost of 3 YGO structure decks.

Decklist:
22
4 Fleecemane
4 Deathdealer
3 Anafenza
2 Courser
4 Rhino
4 Wingmate
1 Tasigur

11
2 Thoughtseize
3 Bile Blight
3 Abzan Charm
3 Hero's Downfall

2
2 Sorin

25
4 Citadel
4 Heath
4 Temple of Malady
2 Temple of Silence
3 Caves
2 Llanowar
2 Urborg
2 Forest
2 Plains

15
2 Thoughtseize
2 Back to Nature
1 Bile Blight
3 Glare
3 Sorrow
2 Nissa
1 Ajani
1 Liliana

Friday, February 13, 2015

YCS Tacoma/Seattle Primer

Originally I was going to write a recap of ARG Ft Worth but I figured it being the event before Nekroz was released made it rather irrelevant. It was so irrelevant that I didn't even really bother following it, at least to the extent that I have for previous events. I saw that Satellars won, which just made me chuckle as I know I've hated on that deck for the past few months now. I think with the recent trend of decks basically running no back row that Satellars were able to capitalize on this so they wouldn't get blown out by Fire Lake. I mean if BA only plays like 2 Emptiness 2 Fire Lake as their backrow line-up, basically MST'ing something is a fairly safe move. If you hit the 1 down and it's Fire Lake then as long as you have an Alpha or something you're free to set your entire backrow without fear of getting blown out. I think Satellars winning was more of a "right place at the right time" instance rather than being the actual best deck. Over the weekend I actually ended up following the Magic Pro Tour instead. Now my interest for the Modern format is rather minimal because financially it's not as accessible as Standard is and I didn't know too much about the format or what the decks did but it was still great watching some of Magic's greatest pros go head to head. The quality of coverage just blew me away, I knew it was basically how Magic has always done it but after watching Yugioh "coverage" for so long I had forgotten what good coverage looks like. All of the commentators knew what they were talking about and what the cards did as they were played, they discussed sidedeck and draft strategies, conducted player interviews, commentators acted and dressed professionally, the list goes on. Yugioh simply still has such a long ways to go, which is sad as the game is certainly not new or anything. Anyways, the problem with Modern, at least from what I can tell, is it reminds me of Yugioh. The top 8 was 2 Bloom, 2 Twin, 2 Burn, and 2 Abzan. So basically 4 combo decks, 2 burn decks, and 2 decks that wanted to actually play Magic. I say it reminds me of Yugioh because those combo decks have the potential to OTK out of nowhere and burn is the same degenerate strategy as it is in any other game. I didn't get away from one self-touch game just to play in another. Furthermore the finals was Twin vs Bloom. I watched the first 2 games where game 1 Bloom combo'd off, and game 2 Twin dropped Blood Moon which made it so the Bloom player couldn't play. At that point I stopped watching because Twin could just Blood Moon the Bloom player out of the rest of the games and sure enough Twin won. Blood Moon is essentially a floodgate that says "you can't play Magic". Again, I've dealt with enough floodgate shit in Yugioh that I just wouldn't be interested in having to deal with that in Magic as well. Luckily those cards either aren't in Standard or just no one plays them.

The big talk in the Yugioh world, for what has felt like the past few months now but is really starting to ramp up, is Nekroz. Tacoma will be the first event that they are legal (inconveniently only a day after release) and I for one am quite interested to see the impact they will have. I know they will do well, I just want to see how well. The pull rates for the good cards is reportedly absurdly low, in the realm of 1 Trish/Brio out of 6 boxes. Seeing this is frustrating as I felt that Konami could've made the deck really accessible to a larger player base by making essentially a Hidden Arsenal set for them. I remember in Hidden Arsenal 1 you could buy 1 box and for the most part be sure to pull 1 each of Catastor, Brio, and Mist Wurm (which were pretty much the only cards people actually wanted). Now you have to buy a case just for the chance to pull 2 of something? In a 60-card set? My God that is absolutely ridiculous. It is just yet another slap in the face to the players that have still stuck around with this game and wanted some possibility or hope of being able to play a tier deck that would be budget. I got to the point where I was finally done with it and I know a lot of other players have as well. I'm guessing Nekroz will be the most expensive deck in the format and if the hype correlates with the results, it will end up being the best deck as well. Going into the event I know there will be a lot of BA, Qliphort, Shaddoll, and Satellars as Nekroz just isn't accessible as it should or could be to the player base. This puts players into an awkward position of "how much should I be siding for this match-up?" Theoretically you might not need to because the odds of running into it (especially in the earlier rounds) would be low, but if you do well and end up seeing a lot of Nekroz in the later rounds you wouldn't wanted to be ill-prepared as well. I remember at the previous Tacoma/Seattle YCS it was when Mermails had just come out and I remember a lot of us wondering how much we should be siding for it. My guess is the upper echelon of pros will be playing Nekroz since they will have easier access to the deck through their sponsor or their network of other pros/friends. I'm not saying everyone that will be playing Nekroz will be good, cuz who knows maybe they just have money but haven't bothered learning the deck, but my guess is that the guys like those in the ARG crew will be running the deck and will be very up-to-speed with it. I think the event will ultimately boil down to "Nekroz vs anti-Nekroz strategies" where the non-Nekroz decks will try to flood Nekroz out of the game and Nekroz will have to out-draw those floodgates. Kinda reminds me of Dragons vs Anti-Dragons. I haven't done a whole lot of testing but I think Qliphorts are the best non-Nekroz deck in a meta with Nekroz. The match-up for Burning Abyss is so skewed in favor of the Nekroz player that I honestly wouldn't even consider playing BA if I were playing the game. Now I might be totally wrong, and I'm not saying that we won't see BA top. I'm sure we will, I just think as the format progresses we will definitely see less of it than we used to and it will evolve into Nekroz and Qliphs being the 2 best decks. I'm not sure where Satellas fits into all this and Shaddolls have shown themselves to be straggling in the race to keep up. The water fusion is not going to cut it when Cross Souls comes out. I think as people increase their anti-search cards to deal with Nekroz this will have a negative impact on Satellas.

I have a few friends that are going to the event so I just wanted to wish them good luck! I hope to God they are prepared for Nekroz. The Seattle ARG was a disappointing event for them so hopefully this event will turn out better. I will not be going since a) I don't have a deck and b) it's Valentine's weekend and I'm married. Originally I was actually going to judge the event and got accepted to do it, but had to opt out of the event due to my general lack of interest in the game, not feeling comfortable with rulings related to the newer cards, and again Valentine's day. Hopefully the event goes well for everyone, players and staff included!

Thursday, January 29, 2015

The Idiot's Guide to Selling Cards

Hi everyone, I apologize as it has been a few weeks since I've last posted, but I have basically gone full-bore into my re-transition into Magic and out of Yugioh. It has been interesting as people locally have caught wind of this and suddenly I'm "so out of the game" that either my opinion doesn't matter any more or I have no concept of rulings any more, which is quite laughable on both accounts. Like I have said before, even if I am not playing the game I will still have an idea of what is going on, what the cards do, event results, etc. I can easily start YGOPRO and play a game of Yugz. Owning paper cards has become pointless and simply a bad investment to play the game locally. On our local Spokane Facebook group one of my friends (who says he is very serious about playing again) asked what Farfa "stood for", as if it was an acronym for something when another person had mentioned how good Farfa is. Now I guess I can see how he thought Farfa was a new combo or deck type or something, but I knew what Farfa was weeks before the set was even released. I had to explain that it was a single BA card. That is the difference between being "active but not playing" vs "not active but playing". Some seem to automatically think that if you aren't playing you're not active. I don't care how often one plays at tournaments, I'd rather be well-researched and out of practice than well-practiced but clueless.

As for Magic, I had Mardu Midrange after I won an eBay auction for a main and side and took it to an FNM but I personally didn't like how the deck flowed. My sideboard wasn't complete enough to address certain match-ups which I hadn't expected to be there. I went a decent 2-2, unfortunately I got mana screwed games 1 and 3 in my round 1 match and blown out by Green Black Devotion (Constellation?). I feel that if I had won my first match, which I am fairly sure I would have if not for being stuck on 2 land game 1 and only Mountains game 3, I would have finished well enough for prizing. I know people roll their eyes when you say you lost because of mana screw, but here is what happened. In game 1 I was on the draw and opened 2 land, a 2-drop, and 4 other cards (which I don't remember at this time). I figured being on the draw, by my 3rd turn I should have drawn into a 3rd land so most of my cards would be live at that point and the hand was keepable enough. Unfortunately that 3rd land didn't come till about my 6th turn, and at that point I was simply too far behind. In game 3 I was forced to mulligan due to having 1 land in my starting 7, and in my opening 6 I opened double Mountain, Hordling Outburst, and 3 other cards. I figured if I topped another land at least I could cast Outburst and if I drew a land which could produce non-red mana I was good. Unfortunately I drew into another Mountain and that was it for the rest of the game. I personally hate the idea of having to mulligan down to 5 since the odds of opening a playable hand goes down dramatically. I still feel that both of my decisions to keep at the point that I did were sound. Even though it was only 1 FNM I had a strong enough of an experience throughout the tournament to where I could tell that the deck had certain paradoxes that I didn't want to be responsible for for solving. I didn't end up getting mana screwed throughout the entire tournament or anything, I could just tell it almost felt too reliant on certain 2-card combos to be truly efficient. I ended up beating a Jeskai deck and a mirror match in case anyone was curious what my 2 wins were lol. I would imagine there's a reason why Mardu's good results seem to come in waves- sometimes you see it top quite a bit, sometimes not at all. In any regard that was enough reason for me to sell Mardu and make the switch to Abzan, which I am waiting for my last few cards to arrive in the mail. Once that happens I want to make my strong push to play again regularly, at least as regularly as I can. I don't have aspirations to be on the Pro Tour or anything, I just want to play a game where I know people will show up and with so many showing up the prize support will justify my deck investment.

The rest of this post is dedicated to the title of said post, basically an "idiot's" guide to selling cards. I use the term idiot very loosely and it is not meant to cause offense. Basically I have seen a lot of "idiotic" practices lately, locally, to where I wanted to write about how people "should" do things, or at least take those things into consideration when it comes to selling cards. A lot of what I have to say should just be common sense. Now if it's not I am not saying you're an idiot. If you learn something or have an "a-ha" moment, that's great. If it's all "well no shit Sherlock" for you, that's great cuz you are experienced enough to where this is common sense. Sorry for having wasted your time in that case.

Concept 1: Selling in "tiers"
When I sell cards, I use this concept/philosophy all the time. Essentially my preferred method of selling is to sell in 3 "waves" or "tiers". 1) sell locally, 2) sell to the vendor/ebay, 3) sell a "bulk" binder on eBay. For the most part, selling in this manner has allowed me to maximize my profits while also clearing the majority of whatever it is I'm trying to sell. It shouldn't be any sort of earth-shattering news that selling locally is the best way to sell a card. This isn't taking into consideration outlier scenarios like your local being entirely composed of people with no jobs, no disposable income, or on the other end of the spectrum where everyone pre-orders everything they want, and only order online and don't buy locally. I have to assume that people are willing to buy cards locally. When you sell locally you don't have to pay any fees, don't have to ship anything, don't have to have a Paypal account, etc. Usually it's a straight cash-for-card transaction. I will talk about using discounts in its own section later on. From there, after I've sold off what I could locally, my next move is to sell to the vendor (usually CoreTCG) or try my hand at eBay. This is where you have to be a little picky since sometimes it's "worth it" to sell a card to the vendor, other times not. For example recently I sold my friend's DT Lavalval Chain for him and I had 2 options: sell it to Core for $20, or try my hand at eBay. I had seen that DT Chains were going for around $40, so clearly the better option was to try and sell it on eBay. Fees and shipping generally account for 14% of an eBay sale, so if the card sold for $40 I would end up with roughly $34.40. The extra $14 was worth the trouble. I ended up accepting a best offer of $35 for it, to where the final value was basically $30. An extra $10 is still an extra $10 so ultimately this was still worth it. If that margin was $3 or less it would be debatable I think. I suppose there could be a 3rd category within this grouping of "Facebook/trade forum" with Pojo being a trade forum for example. There are a lot of big Facebook groups where you can sell your cards to other people and the Pojo trade forum is still going strong after all these years. I personally don't partake in these methods any more but this would be a viable option since you aren't having to pay fees and shipping can be negotiated. Paypal Gift is a good option. You just have to trust that you won't get ripped. And finally, after I've gotten rid of stuff that was worth selling to the vendor or on eBay, I create a binder that I can sell on eBay. A lot of times this is entirely comprised of bulk holos, cheapy rares and commons, or sometimes good cards that the vendor just wasn't buying at the time for what ever reason. This is a good way to just "get rid of everything else" and I will talk more about that in a bit.

Concept 2: Being cheap can cost you in the long run
In a nutshell, this concept says that those who are so stingy that they need to get every single dollar out of a deal they possibly can, can end up losing out in the long run. Previously I had highlighted how my friend's $40 Lavalval Chain pocketed him $30. This was good since otherwise he would've got $20 from the vendor, but let's say we had tried selling this locally. A lot of times I see people be very firm in their prices, to where they would say "it's $40 on eBay so I want $40 for it." They feel that since that's how much it would cost that person to order it online, they should be willing to pay that price, especially for the convenience of not having to wait for it to be shipped to you. I understand that logic and it's not necessarily flawed if you look at it strictly in that sense. As for me, I have always utilized a general "85% of eBay" pricing system for whenever I'm try to sell something, especially quickly. In this Lavalval Chain example, I would have been plenty happy to sell it for $35. I am making more than if I had sold it online, but more importantly, I MAKE MY CUSTOMER HAPPY. People underestimate the importance of this so much. By accepting to sell my card for a discount, I present an image that I am looking out for this person and am reasonable to do business with. The customer leaves happy knowing he got a deal and now has more reason to come back to me for any future card purchases. In his mind he'll know he can get cards off me for less than online, and in my mind I know I'll have a higher payout than if I had sold it to the vendor or eBay.  Having future guaranteed sales is much more valuable than getting that immediate gratification of knowing you squeezed that extra $5 out of the person. People don't realize this, and wonder why they can't sell stuff locally that often or why they're perceived as being a cheapskate. With this, it's also important to remember that Yugioh cards depreciate- FAST. I'm not saying that Magic cards don't, because they certainly do, but very rarely do Yugioh cards retain value due to the "random" nature that is reprints, the ban list, and power creep. In Magic you can keep Standard cards that are powerful enough to impact Modern and Legacy, and generally those cards will go up as time goes on. Chances are it's not getting randomly reprinted. I wish I still had my $20 Tarmogoyfs from way back when, because now they are worth roughly $150 a piece, even after seeing a reprint in Modern Masters (albeit it was a low-printed set). That really doesn't happen in Yugioh because reprints make a card extremely easy to get or the card just isn't viable any more. But back to my point, for the most part it's much better to sell Yugioh quicker, even at a discount, than holding out for more to the point that your card is now worth less than if you had sold it in the first place for that initial discounted price. I know sometimes cards do spike, Denko being a recent example, but that is not a reason to be stingy on everything. For every 1 "loss" you might have, you'll have 9 that could be considered "wins", and that's a damn good ratio.

Concept 3: Image is everything
It is true that we live in a visual-stimulus based society. We want with our eyes. We like shiny things, the bigger and fancier the better, etc. This being said, why is it that people seem to think it's acceptable to make listings, or Facebook posts, with no pictures, description, detail, or anything? For example I've seen local posts like "selling my binder for $200, hit me up" or "selling my Satellarknight deck, it's worth $200 but I'll let it go for $170." And that's it. No pictures, no decklist, nothin. Now it is true that if one was interested enough that they could inquire and say "pictures/decklist please", but as an immediate-gratification/"we want it now" society, what reason do we have to bother having to do so? Especially taking into consideration that they're going to have to PM each person pictures of whatever it is they're trying to sell. Seems like a complete waste of time when those pictures could have been posted originally. You don't see eBay listings without pictures, you don't see Craigslist ads without pictures. Or if you do, chances are those are the auctions that aren't being sold. I know if I look at a Craigslist ad, I immediately ignore it if it doesn't have pictures. When you go to McDonald's there is no such thing as "mystery burger" where you literally have no idea, not even visually, of what you're buying. At the grocery store you don't see a "mystery box of groceries" being sold for $20. People don't like having to wonder when it comes to spending their money. Now if it is a raffle or "grab bag" kind of thing then yes that can be understandable, but when you give info you should provide all the info. Now I understand that sometimes if you buy a used car or a house for example, you don't get all the details for the best interest of the seller. They are afraid that if the buyer knew, it would lead to a no-sale. This is just straight up dishonesty in my opinion, and like I mentioned before they would not have a returning customer. In certain scenarios it won't matter because if I bought the house I'm probably not buying another one next week, but for the most part, for most goods, it will have an impact.

This concept connects back to the eBay "bulk" binder I mentioned previously. With good presentation, you can make shit look like gold. When I'm reduced to a large amount of bulk, what I do is try to take 12 "really good" pictures, at least the best that I can. What I mean is even if the best things you have left are $1 or $2 holos, take as many of those cards you have, and take pictures of those. Lump them together as much as you can, rather than spreading them out to where you might have 1 on each page of your binder. The reason for this is eBay has a picture limit of 12. And since people like pictures, and they like shiny things (aka desirable items), you want to take the 12 pictures that shows as much good stuff as possible. Because all of the other pages, unless you're gonna go through the trouble of typing it all out, don't even matter. If you have a page of Secret Tour Guides but they're not pictured or placed in your description, to the buyer it's not going to matter. Now I know that is an extreme example and if you had a page of Secret Guides you would include a picture of that, but the point is that beyond those 12 pictures it doesn't really matter unless you specifically state what those pages comprise of in your listing. So make those 12 pictures really count! I usually don't even resort to using 2 of the pictures being pictures of the binder itself, because in my opinion if someone is going to buy a binder of cards from you, they're way more interested in the cards than the binder itself. The binder is basically a throw-in but it's also important that it's not basically falling apart at the seams. Again, presentation. Also, the way you lay out your binder is also key. What I mean is organize the shit into categories- what I do is XYZs, Synchros, Other (Ritual/Fusion/Pendulum), Effect monsters, then spells and then traps, with each type having an order based on rarity going from Secret to Common. People don't like looking at a page in your binder where you just have a random vomit of a Synchro, 2 Spells, 2 XYZs, a trap, 2 effect monsters, and a normal Hidden Arsenal monster. It just looks unprofessional, a jumbled mess, and more importantly it makes it look like YOU DON'T CARE. If I'm wanting to buy something from you but my perception is that you don't care, then how confident could I be that your cards are even in good condition, or that you took care of them, when you don't care enough to organize your binder? Again, perception and presentation are everything when it comes to selling. I have sold binders of cards that wouldn't have otherwise been movable locally or even to the vendor. If you have bulk cards and bulk binders, this is an excellent way of clearing your inventory. But you have to care enough to make it look like you care, and that comes in the presentation. Everyone has a cell phone these days and thus access to a camera. Internet is also accessible. So don't be lazy, and don't make excuses. Put in the effort and you will find that, over time, you'll be paid back for it.

Concept 4: Trade for value
I know that many have the mindset that trading a $100 card for 100 $1 cards is stupid. A lot of the times, yes, that is stupid because it's easier to move a single sought-after card than a hundred cards that aren't. But in some cases, what if no one locally is willing to pay $100 for it? Or the vendor is paying $70 on it, and if you sold it on eBay you'd get $85? And in the same light, what if the vendor was paying the full $1 on those 100 cards? You can see that if your intention was just to get money, selling those hundred cards for $1 each would be more profitable. Again this is an extreme example but it can go to show you that sometimes trading down can be the profitable move. A lot of the times when you trade down you can get a higher trade value out of it, and depending on what cards you're getting, can potentially flip those cards to a large number of people for potentially higher profit. Let's say instead of 100 $1 cards you got 5 $20 ones, or lucky enough to get 6 (which would already be a profit). What if one of those cards suddenly spiked to $40 and one of those you were able to trade for a $25 card? Now you're in an even more profitable position. This can connect back to the basic stock philosophy of diversification - basically you don't want all your eggs in one basket, cuz if that basket were to be dropped you would lose all your eggs. Again, simple concepts, but you see a lot of people, especially the hoarder types, with pages of some X card that's really valuable, and suddenly it gets reprinted or it does bad at a YCS and just as suddenly they lose a great amount of value that they can't regain. It's important to be mindful of buylist prices since there are a lot of "random" cards that you wouldn't initially guess would have value, but actually do, at least to a vendor. A person might gladly trade their Magician of Black Chaos or Dark Paladin away because there is simply no playability value to them and in return receive something actually playable. In those cases I don't see the trade as being a "rip" of any kind, when both sides are happy with what they received.

That about wraps up my personal philosophies in selling cards. These concepts can be applied to selling anything, in general. Of course these are generalities and I'm not trying to say "you HAVE to include pictures if you want to sell something", but I don't think I'm entirely out of the ballpark in these concepts. I have been selling things ever since I was a little kid so I feel that I have some sense of what I'm talking about. Very rarely have I ever gotten "stuck" with something, again this ties back to flipping sooner rather than later. "A bird in the hand is worth 2 in the bush", even though it may be a cheesy saying, is certainly true.

Monday, January 5, 2015

ARG Orlando Re-Cap & Making Transitions

Well I hope everyone is enjoying the start of their new year and the changes that the ban list brought about. Judging from the past ARG, realistically not much has changed in terms of the format, other than Snatch coming back and sacking wins just like it used to. I didn't happen to watch the coverage or anything but followed the event via DGz and occasionally look at the standings while also taking care of some business and scoping out a box tournament for Magic. People may not be aware but an incident involving Dalton and based loli occurred, basically a similar story to the "Frazier and Billy" incident that occurred during Dragon format involving forgetting to use Tempest's search effect. You can read all about it on DGz if you were curious. Reading it just makes me shake my head with how far some people will go to ensure victory, especially when those involved are considered to be friends.

As for the ARG, we saw a top 16 breakdown of 6 Qliphort, 5 Burning Abyss, 4 Shaddoll, and 1 Satellarknights. Looks basically identical to past events of last format and going into the event I felt that this would be the case. It's not like Tengu going to 3 was going to do anything. The finals was a Burning Abyss-Shaddoll matchup where BA won, again not too big of a surprise. The most notable shift I observed was the change in the BA trap line-up, with some builds excluding PWWB and Karma Cut altogether. This would make sense in an effort to adapt to Denko Dolls and improve its matchup, at least in having fewer cards that could get locked up due to Denko. Other notable changes (at least what I noticed) include the increased usage of maindeck Maxx C, decreased usage of Odd-Eyes in Qliphorts, and increased usage of Night Beam (to where Qliphort TCG lists are looking more similar to older OCG lists). With the new set coming out in a matter of weeks, and the Hero structure deck, and then the Nekroz set shortly thereafter, I could see the game shifting more significantly than it has in the past several weeks. From the minimal amount of testing I've done with and against Nekroz, I can almost guarantee things will change, even if it just means using different floodgates or side cards, or maybe effect negation like Veiler and Breakthrough will become more popular again just to deal with Trish. The true top-tier decks will most likely be able to adapt and hold on (especially since they're getting their own grip of support cards) but I feel that decks like Satella will fall off completely and I still question Shaddolls' long-term longevity, especially with their support being much less substantial than Qli or BA.

Recently I have decided to sell off the large majority of my collection and purchased a Magic deck to get back in the game. I know I have expressed my disappointment several times in the past regarding local attendance, and paired with a few other personal things, have decided I will be shifting my focus from Yugz to Magic. With Saturday not really being a tourney anymore (a whole 4 people showed up with 2 of them being myself and Danny) and me not being able to attend Mondays, that only leaves Sundays, which I have heard has been on the decline. I actually stopped by yesterday to sell some stuff and there surprisingly was a decent number of people there (like 15 I think, which I would say is average or slightly above average) but it is still nothing consistent (could just as easily be 8 the next tourney) and at one tourney a week would err on the side that would say the investment isn't worth it. I don't envision playing Magic 3 days a week or anything but with a box tournament every week and knowing I can hit a Standard event almost any day of the week and know there'll be a decent number of people there, gives me much more confidence in Magic. More people brings more prize support, and the larger events that do exist bring substantial prizing in themselves. It's basically too good to pass up especially with the state of Yugz locally. This is not to say that I am getting completely out of Yugz though, as I have told others that even if I were to completely quit the game, I would still be more involved with the game than some people that actually play; mostly in the research department like keeping up with trends in the game and what's coming out, and also in testing due to the impeccable accessibility the mobile version of YGOPro provides. I guess that couldn't be classified as "quitting the game" then lol. I just don't see myself quitting to the point that I'd have 0 involvement in the game- even if they stopped making product I'd still be down for a game of Goats lol. You could say I'd be part-time, or semi part-time. There's still incentive to hit a box tourney when they do occur and judging regionals and whatnot but as far as putting in a genuine effort to play at locals, I just don't see it happening unless the game somehow became immensely healthier on the local level- I'm talking 30+ people on a consistent basis. It is sad because I know we have the physical player base to have these kinds of numbers again, but people just don't show up for some reason or the other (which I know numerous legitimate reasons exist).

As for the blog, I would imagine that I'd be writing more about Magic and probably the same amount as I have been for Yugioh. I know that is not a lot, but like I said I'm still going to be following what happens at events and know what's going on in the game. Occasionally I'll have enough of an opinion about those things to write about them! Seems like a win-win lol. So with that, I suppose I'll jump right away into talking about Magic. I would say the hardest part of transitioning into the game is the amount of research it takes to get "caught up". This Standard format has shown to be incredibly diverse and with that I know there are still some decks I don't have a grasp on what they try to accomplish. I remember reading from Grand Prix Denver coverage that at the end of round 7 there were like 12 different decks that were undefeated at that point. Abzhan showed itself to be the most dominant strategy, but Blue-Black control ended up winning the event. The general consensus seems to be that basically anything can win in the hands of the right player and a little bit of luck, but with Fate Reforged coming out very shortly we'll see how that may or may not change. Buying a deck right before a set being introduced into the game makes me slightly nervous, but Standard is said to change so often that ultimately I don't think it will matter; I can't keep waiting for the next set or rotation or event or whatever to occur. If I have to move something then I'm confident I'll be able to in some capacity. I'm hoping that this week will be my first local event so I am rather excited. When you're starting from the bottom, the only place you have to go is up!

Wednesday, December 17, 2014

January 1 2015 Forbidden & Limited List Discussion

Well for anyone who may have missed out on the news earlier today, Konami has officially posted the new ban list on their page, which can be found here. I actually wasn't quite expecting it to come out so soon, I was thinking maybe next Tuesday, but hey that is sweet of them, at least it gives people more time to test out the new format in preparation for ARG Orlando (I know Konami doesn't give a shit about that, but still).

Here are the changes to the list, for reference:
Forbidden:
Super Polymerization

Limited:
Artifact Moralltach
Dark Strike Fighter
Snatch Steal

Semi-Limited:
Honest
Goyo Guardian
Dark Hole

No longer Limited:
Blackwing - Gale the Whirlwind
Mermail Abyssgunde
Reborn Tengu
Reasoning
Transmigration Prophecy

This list will go into effect until March 31, so we'll have another 3-month format. From looking at the list overall, it basically looks like the exact same format as the post-NECH one we're in now. No hits to Burning Abyss or Qliphort, Shaddolls lose a Super Poly, and Satellas gain another Honest, if they were even playing the 1 anyway. My prediction is that at the YCS and ARG level we'll see the same decks topping in similar numbers, and Nekroz will join the fray come February. I'm not sure how Heroes will do. People will try to get cute with Reborn Tengu, whether it be in a re-creation of the old Tengu Plant deck, throw a set into Fire Fist since it's a Beast-Warrior, or maybe something like Hand-Tengu-Traptrix as a floater-based deck. I think these strategies will fall flat though as they are rather outdated and don't really stand out as better decks than the "Big 3" we have now.

I guess I'll go through every change and give my opinion on it:
Super Poly banned
Overall I'm glad for this change, as I don't think there should be any card in the game that says "you can't respond to this." From my experience newer players would always get confused about it, like they would either Warning it or use Shi-En to negate it, and I've lost Shaddoll mirrors where I've been in control solely due to this card. It's a minor change but indirectly hits Shaddolls and Hero-based decks. I had predicted that BLS would be banned, but I guess he lives to sack through another format.

Moralltach, DSF, and Snatch to 1
Well I had predicted there would be no hits to the Artifact engine, and I was way wrong. I'm rather surprised by this because now if they reprint Sanctum in something no one is going to give 2 shits. Moralltach left at 3 meant a Sanctum reprint would've appealed to someone somewhere, but now, meh. Dark Strike could be at 3 and probably wouldn't affect anything contrary to how people make it out to seem. The errata was perfect to make it a relatively balanced card. Snatch Steal - god damn Snatch Steal. This change is probably the most shocking one and I can hear the words already - "Snatch for game?" I feel that Snatch is completely sacky and the balanced versions we do have like Mind Control, Puppet Plant/etc, are more than enough. Just because MST exists doesn't mean that Snatch is balanced. This will definitely impact the game.

Honest, Goyo, and Derka Hole to 2
On paper Honest to 2 is a pretty big change, as it gives decks like Lightsworn, Bujins, and Satellas more answers. The first 2 decks basically see no play, and like I said in a previous post, Satellas will be Satellas. I suppose this could also be a boost to decks running Denko Sekkas and gives them a "backrow" card to protect the Denko. I don't know how frequently we'll see 2 Honest in decks that top, but I know the singleton Honest was annoying enough to play against, and surely people will go hammy with an extra. Like DSF, I think Goyo could be at 3 and not do much besides make Blizzard a true all-star for Blackwings. With Raigeki having a "relatively playable" status, and everything being floaters right now, I don't think the second Dark Hole will make much impact. We will probably see more board "resets" but they won't be as back-breaking as they used to.

Gale, Gunde, Tengu, Reasoning, and Transmi to 3
I think Blackwings now have everything back except I suppose the 2nd and 3rd DSF's. Gale does run over quite a bit in the current game but I honestly think even if there was a rule that said "if you're playing Blackwings you are allowed to run 1 Pot of Greed", they still wouldn't do anything. Gale's not even being ran as tech like it used to in stun decks, but then again stun is a hard strategy to make viable right now especially with T-King still at 1. Gunde back to 3 gives Mermails more of a fighting chance, I could see more players picking up Mermails again but I think it is outclassed by the "Big 3" right now. I already talked about Tengu - in certain game states it will definitely be annoying dealing with its uber floater-ness but I don't think it will be a forefront strategy in the meta. Reasoning and Transmi are both "whatever" cards, they could've taken more things back to 3 but baby steps are still forward progress.

A Shift in Focus?
Ever since the TCG and OCG lists became vastly different, we've seen Konami do the TCG lists much differently than what we've been accustomed to. It used to be where you could see a deck be completely obliterated by the ban list (still happened to Infernity, but they've had it coming for years) basically a format or at most two after it came out, and now we're barely seeing any hits at all. Winda/Tour Guide/Dante to 1? Skill Drain or Emptiness to 1? Nope, not a single change. I think for Konami to re-instill some form of confidence from the players they have abandoned this old strategy of completely nuking decks. We saw overall fear by looking at the prices of hot cards over the past few weeks where they've continually declined because they "could get hit." I mean even I sold off Shaddolls and what I had for Burning Abyss "because who knows wtf Konami will do". I still don't think that's necessarily a bad strategy, but maybe we can all chill out a little bit in terms of trying to completely dump off stuff right before a new banlist. I do feel for the people that had the Artifact engine though- pretty soon you won't even be able to give a Sanctum away (sure you can but you know what I mean), let alone sell it. Overall though I think they are realizing that in order for people to keep interest in the game, they can't keep taking away their decks. They can keep making shit that's more broken than those decks and still "sort of" force players in certain directions (at least to be competitively viable), but not outright banning key cards of particular archetypes to essentially kill those decks outright.

The Backrow Dilemma?
Basically throughout this format I've thought to myself about how I thought MST was the most important card in the game. That is not to say I think that every deck needs to run 3, but it has gotten to the point where we need to worry about a plethora of cards that MST helps deal with, most notably Emptiness, Scout, and Fire Lake. Skill Drain to some extent. There is a paradox that exists simply because Fire Lake exists, in that it's always been seen as "bad" to randomly MST a backrow card at the End Phase, or especially during your own Main Phase, but sometimes a gamestate forces the player to ask "well can I afford to get Fire Lake'd?" If the answer is no then you may simply be forced to take that percentage chance of trying to hit it. It is basically why Night Beam has become viable tech, but you're still basically "blind Night Beam"ing. If you're playing a combo deck like Shaddolls or Mermails, MST's and Night Beams only hurt your consistency as all they do is simplify gamestates. But now, are they necessary just because of what we have to deal with? This ties very closely with Snatch Steal being reintroduced; "we have yet another card that we want to hold our MSTs for, on top of Emptiness' and Scouts in Qliphorts, but fuck I don't want to get blown out by Fire Lake so I have to end-phase MST". We're only allowed 3 MSTs, and no matter what people say Twister and Dust Tornado just aren't on MST's caliber. I've seen and experienced losing just because of drawing into too much Spell-Trap destruction with nothing to go along with it. Yes we will try to play around Snatch by holding our MSTs, but there's gonna be times we just lose because we didn't blind-space the Fire Lake or we had to use one earlier on an Emptiness or Scout. This isn't even taking into account any floodgates people can and will side in. It is quite unfortunate - to help out the game they should've hit more of these continuous cards, not give us more to deal with.

Monday, December 8, 2014

December 6/7 Weekend In Review (ARG Atlanta & YCS Milan)

I thought bringing back some form of event result analysis would be beneficial not only for others but for myself so this will be something I try to do more frequently as ARG and YCS events take place. Over the weekend we had 2 events occur (ARG Atlanta and YCS Milan- that's in Italy, it's OK I had to look it up too lol) so I would like to talk about what happened at those events. I believe it is very important that we look at and analyze trends as this helps us be aware of what cards are being ran, how decks look in terms of builds, etc. As they say, knowing is half the battle.

ARG Atlanta
Decklists can be found here.
One of the notable things that people realized early in the event was that Patrick Hoban would not be playing in it. Rather, he provided color commentary for I believe the majority of the event. I'm not exactly sure why he chose not to play at this event but I know quality in general (of the stream itself, commentators, etc) has been put into question so perhaps this was their attempt toward re-establishing viewer confidence. I only watched the coverage for a little bit due to being so busy with holiday-related activities even though I did try to follow along on DGz and via ARG site coverage. There were 237 players at the event, which is roughly the same for Chicago, at 229 players, which occurred the previous weekend. ARG does a good job of posting information on their Facebook page where they provide the deck distribution of all players at the event, top 16, and pairings as the top 16 occurs. I wish they would simply post this on their event coverage as the event was happening though; it seems that for day 2 coverage basically just stops until they post the decklists.

In any regard, we saw the following distribution for all players at the event (source via ARG FB page):
83 Burning Abyss (37%)
45 Shaddolls (not sure why the differentiate Chaos and Artifact) (20%)
41 Qliphort (18%)
24 Satellarknight (11%)
31 Other (14%)

Now there is a slight disparagement between the total players as seen via the standings at the end of round 1 and the total for the numbers above, at 237 vs 224 respectively. I'm not sure what happened to the 13 unaccounted-for duelists but for percentage purposes I had to go with the 224 number.

Clearly we can see that Burning Abyss accounted for the largest percentage of the field. Let's look at the top 16 breakdown:
6 Burning Abyss (37.5%)
5 Qliphort (31.25%)
4 Shaddoll (25%)
1 Satellarknight (6.25%)

Burning Abyss stayed roughly the same in percentage representation from the total player pool to the top 16 at 37%. Qliphort had a considerable rise, going from 18% of the pool up to roughly 31% of the top 16. Shaddoll went up slightly by 5%, and Satellas went down by about 5%. This could lead us to the conclusion that Qliphort may be the best deck to use for those looking to top an event, at least looking at it purely by representation. This is how it would look by considering "what percentage of X players topped?" where X is the particular decktype.
Burning Abyss: 7%
Qliphort: 12%
Shaddoll: 9%
Satella: 4%

So this means that 7% of all the people that played Burning Abyss at the event topped, 12% for Qliphort, etc. If you look at it in this perspective, perhaps Burning Abyss didn't do as well as it should have. Just something to consider because I know a lot of people take the first 2 sets of numbers into consideration but don't take it a step further and consider what percentage of the people that played a particular deck topped. Perhaps it's not even relevant, I'm not exactly sure from a statistical standpoint.

Top 8 breakdown was:
4 Qliphort (50%)
2 Burning Abyss (25%)
2 Shaddoll (25%)

At top 8, Qliphorts seemed well-poised to take this event.

Top 4 breakdown:
1 Qliphort (25%)
2 Burning Abyss (50%)
1 Shaddoll (25%)

Essentially we saw Qliphorts and Burning Abyss switch places in representation. Naturally there was room for this to occur due to a Qliphort mirror-match that occurred whereas each other pairing was a non-mirror.

In the finals we saw Burning Abyss vs Qliphort, with Burning Abyss winning the event once again. Now I didn't watch the final nor do I know the game count for the particular match. It has been said though that Burning Abyss has a good Qliphort match-up due to the disruption that Abyss naturally has. I believe Based Loli (who won the event) was in a great position to take the tournament as he never had to play the deck's arguably hardest match-up, Shaddoll, at all in top 16. This is attributed to Qliphorts beating out the Shaddoll players (which Shaddolls are said to have a bad Qliphort match-up), and Ben Leverett winning his Shaddoll match in top 8.

YCS Milan
Now I know, for some reason, that American players seem to disregard anything that happens in Europe as far as YGO goes. The difference between how much we pay attention to something like US Nats, vs Euro Nats, is quite remarkable considering some of the world's best players come from Europe. There was quite a large turnout at 1461 duelists. For total participants we saw the following deck distribution:
485 Shaddoll (again I hate the separation of Chaos and Artifact) (33%)
338 Burning Abyss (23%)
259 Qliphort (18%)
113 Satella (8%)
266 Other (18%)

Top 32 breakdown was:
11 Burning Abyss (34%)
11 Shaddoll (34%)
9 Qliphort (28%)
1 Evilswarm (3%)

We can see that Burning Abyss and Qliphort had roughly the same percentage distribution as ARG Atlanta, whereas Shaddoll did considerably better. The lone Evilswarm player getting it in lol. Comparing the ratio between total participants and top 32 representation, we saw the greatest difference in Abyss and Qliphort, at roughly at 10% increase in both.

As for the rest of the breakdowns, all they gave us was the names of who was facing who, rather than including what deck they were running. As far as I can see there also isn't a list of "who played what" besides the top 8, so this will have to be skipped.

In top 8 we saw:
3 Qliphort (37.5%)
3 Burning Abyss (37.5%)
1 Shaddoll (12.5%)
1 Evilswarm (12.5%)

Evilswarm managed to make it top 8 which is pretty remarkable but is arguably better positioned now than it may have been in the past format or two, at least with Shaddoll's popularity.

In top 4 we saw:
2 Qliphort
2 Abyss

We are once back to the match-up between arguably the 2 best decks in the current game with no mirror-matches. Theoretically Abyss was in a great position to take this event as well but we had a winner in each to where the final would be Qliphort vs Abyss. In what could be considered a surprise win, Daniele Stella won with Qliphorts. I thought it would've been funny if Mr. Stella won with Satellas, but perhaps that is just my sense of humor lol.

Trending Up, Trending Down
I'd like to commit this section to trends I notice and will focus on ARG Atlanta as all of the decklists are readily available.
Trending Up:
Denko Sekka
All of the Shaddoll players that topped at this event ran some number of Denko Sekka. Its viability was questionable when the card first came out, but has proven itself to be a potential blowout card and valuable tool to overcome and lock out valuable backrow.

Night Beam
We have seen this emerge as essentially a 4th MST but one that we can be used to stymie anything that could be chainable. Its usage has continued to hold and isn't just a one-event tech.

Maxx C
Hand traps (Veiler and Maxx) saw very little play for a period of time as they basically did very little at the time. Now Maxx has seen an upswing, most likely to combat Burning Abyss and make them stop from combo'ing off.

Enemy Controller
Like Night Beam, we have seen this card's usage explode in numbers and again it has held strong in Abyss and Shaddoll decks. The interactions it has is definitely interesting.

About the Same:
Fiend side
Both Fiends, Majesty's and Vanity's, are continuing to see sideboard play to combat the meta and create a lock-down situation for the opponent. Enemy Controller's popularity could be a direct correlation with this as it provides an avenue for tribute fodder to summon the Fiends, or put them in defense mode to run over the opponent's. Like I predicted earlier in the format, the emergence of tech would occur once again in a 2 or 3-deck format.

Ojama Trio side
It is funny this card has emerged as tech as my teammate Drew mentioned this card as a potential card vs Abyss or decks that can spam a lot. I still have my apprehensions of the card itself, as I feel that all it does is help you stall a few turns and isn't really winning you the game per se, but nonetheless it has been holding its usage.

Fairy Wind
Fairy Wind has seen a great amount of usage with the emergence of Qliphort and is the favored sided-in mass-S/T destruction card. Spell Shattering Arrow is also a popular option, but not as popular as Fairy Wind has been.

Trending Down:
Artifacts
For a period of time we saw virtually every deck try to squeeze in the Artifact engine as a means of disruption and changing the momentum. This strategy has virtually fallen off the map, with Shaddolls still holding onto it the longest, but the Denko/Chaos variant proving to yield more positive results.

Hands
The hands, Fire and Ice, similar to Artifacts, were often seen either splashed into the main or used in the side to circumvent floodgates or problematic monsters. They were held in fairly high regard in the Qliphort match-up, where they would be unhindered by Skill Drain and they would be free to wipe the field but players have not been going with this approach, most likely due to the high commitment of the side. These could see a re-emergence once Nekroz are released but for the time being they are virtually unplayed.

Solemn Warning/Non-Chainable removal
Solemn Warning was once considered a staple card as it stopped nearly every special summon effect in the game. It still does, but perhaps the life point cost and the fact it is a non-chainable form of removal makes it unappealing. Cards like Dimensional Prison, Bottomless, and Fiendish Chain, have all seen a uniformly decreased amount of play. Compulsory is still holding a little play due to it being a chainable out to Winda.

Flying C/Stygian Dirge
At one point these were fairly popular side cards vs decks like Burning Abyss that relied on XYZ plays. C still seems some play, but not to the extent that it used to and Dirge has fallen off.

Monarch side
This could be a direct correlation with a decrease in Flying C usage, where Burning Abyss players considered siding in Raiza, Caius, or Mobius as a way of getting Flying C off the field while also providing field disruption. This strategy is basically unseen and the Fiend side is a more popularized option.

Trap Stun/Wiretap
Theoretically these cards are the best answers to blowout traps like Fire Lake, but they have seen a continual decrease in usage as the format has progressed. Indeed the format has become more monster-heavy, and neither Stun or Tap do much in that regard besides making your own plays go through, but for Shaddolls Denko basically fills that role now and Abyss naturally have Fire Lake. Qliphorts basically don't care as they have built-in forms of recursion.

The "Unique Tech" Award:
If there was such a thing as receiving an award for playing the most unique tech at an event (not to be confused with troll card), it would have to be a tie between Ben Leverett's Revival Gift, and Casey Barbee's Storm. I know Storm was considered for a while but as far as I know this is the first time we've seen it in a decklist that has topped a premier event. It will be interesting to see if these cards see any additional play in future events.

That about wraps up this very long analysis of the events that took place over the weekend. If anyone has any ideas of other things/aspects I can analyze please feel free to leave a comment.

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Jan 1 2015 Banlist Insight

I hope everyone had a great Thanksgiving and is enjoying the holiday season so far. It's crazy to think we're only probably about 3 weeks away from getting a new ban list so I thought I would take the time to discuss what I could see happening in terms of what gets hit, etc. I chose to call this "Insight" as opposed to "Prediction" since I'm not outright saying (intentionally) "well this is what I think will happen", rather, something more along the lines of "this is my rationale for why I think this could happen, but if it doesn't, it wouldn't surprise me." After all, predicting what Konami will do for our ban list has become much harder to do over the past few lists.

1. Vanity's Emptiness
I haven't seen much in terms of articles or videos of list predictions for this format yet, but I know this card in particular has been discussed over the past few lists. With special summoning being a forefront strategy for basically every deck, you could say this is the ultimate generic floodgate card in the current game. Some see Emptiness and hate on it (probably just because it's so expensive) while others feel it is just a necessary evil. Without a card like this or Oppression in the game, spammy decks would be free to just OTK as long as they could get through the other backrow. A part of me could easily see this card going to 1, but I also believe they haven't milked the card enough quite yet by providing an easier-to-obtain form of it considering it is so sought-after. But then again Konami has shown that they don't care in the past. I would argue that Emptiness is harder to obtain than Dante, not because of its rarity or price, but because people are more inclined to hold on to a set of Emptiness over Dante, simply because Emptiness is much more generic whereas Dante only goes in 1 deck (2, if you consider Shabyss to be a completely different deck than regular Abyss). I've personally gotten rid of my common playset because I don't want to take that chance of it going to 1, and if it stays at 3 I can easily re-obtain them. If it goes to 1 then everyone will be dumping off their extras where it will then be incredibly easy to obtain (like what happened with Soul Charge).

2. BLS
I remember there being a time when both BLS and DAD basically saw no play, but now BLS is often run in Shaddoll and Abyss, while DAD can be seen in Shaddoll due to Eclipse Wyvern conveniently being a Light. At the right time, BLS can win games all on his own or is a perfect comeback card. This could lead to the notion that the card is sacky. I think it just may be BLS's time to be on the chopping block once again not because of its power alone, but as a way of indirectly hitting Shaddoll and Burning Abyss. It could be argued that once the additional Qliphort support and Nekroz comes out that decks running BLS could naturally get phased out due to power creep, but any deck that runs Darks and Lights can easily splash BLS in as a standalone easily-summonable boss-monster; its presence would always be felt as long as those decks had any sort of viability.

3. Fire Lake
This card just recently came out but its impact has immediately been felt. This can be viewed as an Icarus Attack on crack and bad for the game due to it being a frequent 1-for-3 exchange. It is virtually impossible to establish a field against an unopposed Lake, and an end phase Lake play can absolutely destroy decks like Satellas that rely on their backrow presence to compete with today's meta. Regardless of its power and destruction though, I would be surprised to see this card get hit due to it being in a deck Konami is still pushing support for. It could be argued that BA is so good because of Lake. I know it was still a good deck prior to NECH, but it does give the deck a large bit of power all on its own. Some may say "well they hit Geargiagear even though they got more support", and yes that is true, but when you compare the two Geargiagear required absolutely no set-up, whereas Lake does (even though it's incredibly easy to fulfill its requirements). Geargia support came in the form of a structure deck where people would probably buy 3 anyway so they could either build the deck or obtain some reprint, but Abyss support is coming out in actual sets, where people may be less inclined to purchase it if they had no interest in the other decks that were being supported for in the set. What I am trying to say is that it would be a greater financial risk to hit Burning Abyss right now than it was for them to hit Geargia at the time that they did.

4. Shadow Games
Shadow Games could be viewed as a card that is too versatile due to the versatility of the Shaddoll monsters. Shadow Games can be an MST (Dragon), a Rota (Hedgehog), an Upstart (Beast), a wall (Falco), graveyard manipulation (Squamata), or a momentum changer (Falco+Beast plays etc). That is a lot out of 1 card and since it has been hit in the OCG, people have said it could see a hit for us as well. I could see it going to 2 to little effect but would be very surprised to see it go down to 1. We still have a little more Shaddoll support on the way to consider. I personally don't think they will touch this card, at least for January.

5. Artifact Engine
I think there was a period of time where the Artifact engine was frequently seen or splashed into decks and people felt that they should be hit. Nowadays we see the occasional Shaddoll Artifact deck top but nothing compared to how it was pre-NECH. Like Shadow Games, the OCG has Moralltach at 1. I think they will keep the entire engine intact over here as Sanctum would be one of those cards the casual crowd would ooh and ah over as a tin reprint, even though it may not be seen that often competitively.

6. Mathematician
I feel a bit silly even bringing this card up, but because I have heard talk of how people "could see Math going to 1", I guess it doesn't hurt to talk about it and look at it from both perspectives. I am not discrediting Math man's impact on the game, as a lot of monster effects do occur when they are sent to the grave by a card effect. With a 1500 body and the draw effect on top of it, it's actually really good at the cost of your normal summon. Like BLS, it is indirect support for Shaddoll and Burning Abyss. The difference between Math and BLS though is that Math most likely isn't completely shifting momentum around or outright winning games. I would say by today's game's standards it is actually pretty balanced and I could see this fitting nicely as a tin reprint as well. I would be surprised to see a hit on Math, but if they did I could at least see the rationale behind it and wouldn't completely be "WTF??" like I know others would.

What Could Come Back?
I think we could agree there are a lot of cards that could come off the list to minimal effect and history has proven this; looks at things such as Tsukuyomi, Magician of Faith, and Mirror Force going to 3. Goyo is good but not nearly as absurd as it once was. Even Raigeki went from being a blowout card to a board/tempo-control card since the majority of the competitive monsters now are floaters. With the shorter formats I think Konami can take more "baby-step" unrestrictions like they have been and take things like Sinister Serpent, Tribe, Thousand-Eyes, etc and try them at 1. If they break the format then it is simple enough to ban them again but I think in the majority of cases some of these cards could go to 3 with almost no effect. Obviously I'm not saying "put Ring to 3" or anything absurd like that.

Overall, I actually don't envision much happening on this ban list at all. There may be a couple "!!" changes but I think it will be pretty tame. People will still want to play Abyss, Qliphs, and Nekroz. Shaddolls could go either way, and Satellas will still be Satellas- there, consistent, and with the ability to win, but there won't be a time where it is just straight dominant like how it was after the first ARG they did exceptionally well at.